Russia, Saudi Arabia and Australia have emerged as the world’s three largest historical exporters of carbon dioxide emissions through fossil fuel exports, according to a new analysis released during the ongoing COP31 climate summit in Turkey.
The study, conducted by climate research organization Carbon Brief, examined fossil fuel exports dating back to 1850 and attributed carbon emissions to the countries that extracted and exported the fuels, rather than those where the emissions were ultimately released. The findings present a different perspective on historical responsibility for global climate change.
Russia tops the list, with fossil fuel exports responsible for nearly 70 gigatonnes of carbon dioxide emissions by the end of 2025. Saudi Arabia ranks second with approximately 60 gigatonnes, while Australia is third, accounting for more than 25 gigatonnes of exported emissions, slightly ahead of Venezuela.
The report comes at a sensitive time, as Australia is serving as the president of the COP31 United Nations Climate Summit while continuing to rely heavily on fossil fuel exports, which contribute around 40 percent of the country’s export earnings. Critics argue that Australia’s leadership role at the summit contrasts with its continued support for coal and gas production.
Climate campaigners say the analysis highlights a major imbalance in international climate negotiations. Louise Hutchins, coordinator of the Make Polluters Pay International Coalition, said wealthy fossil fuel-exporting nations have accumulated enormous profits while continuing to hold significant influence over global climate policy. She argued that countries benefiting most from fossil fuel extraction should bear greater financial responsibility for addressing climate damage.
Despite being among the world’s largest current greenhouse gas emitters, the United States and China still rank higher in overall historical emissions because they have burned vast amounts of both imported and domestically produced fossil fuels, the report noted.
The findings have intensified discussions at COP31, where negotiators are debating stronger language on reducing global dependence on fossil fuels. Australia recently proposed draft summit language calling for an “immediate transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems.” However, several countries, including Saudi Arabia, have reportedly opposed stronger commitments, making consensus increasingly difficult.
Separate research released by Climate Analytics also questioned Australia’s domestic climate policies, noting that new coal mines approved in the country could continue operating until 2088, decades beyond the global target of achieving net-zero emissions around the middle of the century.
Responding to the report, Saudi Arabia defended its position, stating that emissions generated from exported oil should primarily be attributed to the countries that consume the fuel. The Saudi Energy Ministry also highlighted efforts to reduce emissions from its oil and gas production, describing its upstream carbon intensity as among the lowest globally.
Climate experts say the latest analysis is likely to fuel fresh debates over climate finance and historical responsibility, with developing nations continuing to demand greater financial contributions from countries that have benefited most from fossil fuel extraction. As COP31 negotiations continue, the question of who should pay for climate damage remains one of the summit’s most contentious issues.